Historical, Legal and Scientific Issues of Paediatric Vaccine Mandates
Abstract:
This review outlines the scientific and legal foundations for a revision of the regulations concerning mandatory vaccinations, with a particular focus on the situation in Italy. The ten vaccines made mandatory by Italian Law No. 119/2017 (against poliomyelitis, diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis, hepatitis B, Haemophilus influenzae type b, measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella) are re-examined, with a particular consideration on their capacity to safeguard public health and, therefore, the interests of the community—a requirement that the Italian Constitution (Article 32) stipulates as a possible justification for mandating a medical treatment. Effects on infection, transmission, and duration of protection differ substantially between vaccines. Their implications regarding the need for vaccination—and the duration of any potential mandate for different segments of the population—must therefore be evaluated separately for each disease. While certain vaccines may be useful in specific epidemiological contexts, there is no justification for a generalized vaccination mandate for children. The analysis further indicates that scientific knowledge gained in recent years through active pharmacovigilance—some of which was not available in 2017—shows that adverse effects of vaccines on children’s health are far from negligible, especially when weighed against the low incidence of most of the infectious diseases in question. This invokes the precautionary principle, a cornerstone of medicine, together with the need for truly informed consent, grounded in real-world data.
Keywords: Vaccine mandates, mandatory vaccination, herd immunity, informed consent, constitution, healthcare legislation
Enjoying this content? Consider making a donation to help us continue to provide quality medical research at no cost.
Share This Article
Stay Connected
You'll receive breaking news, updates, and exclusive content.